10/02/2026
Today I want to talk about something that has been baffling which is when folks who support the president believe things that are absolutely not true. This post is inspired by Robert Reich’s recent Substack about trying to understand MAGA. I remember when I was canvassing I chatted with a woman who, when I asked her if affordability was an issue, told me no that things were much worse under Biden. I’m not sure I was able to hide the confusion that I was feeling because all of the data says that things are worse now in terms of grocery prices, going out to eat, gas prices, etc. Yet, she firmly believed it and said it with conviction. In Reich’s post, he talks about the fact that 53% of Republican voters identify themselves as MAGA. The good news is that 47% of Republican voters do not.
Those who do, however, believe Trump’s lies and will defend them until the end. Some are like my co-coach’s friends who are super rich and love what Trump is doing for their wealth. So they contort themselves to avoid cognitive dissonance as they would not want to believe they, who are educated folks, are following a corrupt, inconsistent, liar. So, instead they spew his lies as if they were truths.
We will have a hard time, convincing folks who are in the cult to believe differently because their leader is telling them what the truth is. The post from a few days about go about how to deal with arguments that they make. These tactics might work with some, but for those who have fully drunk the Kool-Aid, they’re going to need a much deeper intervention to move themselves from the cult.
But what I want us to focus on is that there are many Republicans who do not support Trump right now. Those are the folks we need to be convincing to join us and vote Democrat in the midterms. And remember there are many unaffiliated who voted for Trump but are not MAGA. All of these folks are feeling the pinch of the economy. They’re feeling the absence of immigrants affecting their work. They’re feeling the pressure from the tariffs that are hurting them financially. They are feeling the pinch of healthcare as well. These folks likely will want to vote out the folks who have not been representing them and vote in people who will. We must keep our messages focused on affordability and corruption to help people see that the current administration and those who are supporting them need to go. The lies are only working with a small portion of Americans. There are many who feel the way we do. We need to spread the word and get them to the polls!!! Let’s goooooo!!!!
https://engageddefendersfordemocracy.substack.com/p/drinking-the-kool-aid-blurs-folks?
Good morning Engaged Defenders for Democracy!