09/17/2026
Yet again, last night's ANC 5B meeting ended with a toxic discussion. In this instance the conversation was focused on the Education Committee.
There is valid concern about whether our ANC committees reflect the diversity of the broader community. As commissioners, we have made real efforts to recruit people with different backgrounds, experiences, neighborhoods, and perspectives.
There continues to be a misunderstanding of the role and duties of the ANC and the committee structure. First and foremost, our primary mission is to advocate for residents to the government. Additionally, we are not paid - we are volunteers as are committee members. We can recruit and we can ask people to participate but we cannot force anyone to serve.
The conversation turned toxic when demands were made to account for committee members by race, gender, and how long they have lived in DC. Another resident suggested that committee membership requires being a "native Washingtonian."
I wholeheartedly disagree with the notion of being a Washintonian as a requirement. There is no place for racial tests, demographic tests, or some arbitrary residency test for who is allowed to serve their community. I have lived in Washington for 24 years. That is longer than I lived where I grew up. Am I a Washingtonian yet? If not, when do I become one? At 25 years? 30? 40? And who gets to decide?
There is an important conversation to be had about representation, including the history and experience of longtime residents. But that conversation cannot become a mandate to tell other residents that they are somehow less legitimate because of their race, where they were born, how long they have lived here, what street they happen to live on, or where their children attend school.
If you believe a committee or the ANC itself is missing voices that need to be there, there is a very practical solution: volunteer. Encourage someone you think should be represented to volunteer. Send us names. Help us recruit. But standing on the sidelines and demanding that volunteers justify their race, gender, birthplace, or years of residency is outrageous.
So, respectfully, if you think the committee or the ANC is missing someone, either run or volunteer yourself or help us fill the seat.