10/28/2025
Out of the mouths of…. Journalists.
“Whatever this is, it’s a mess….And now next year’s municipal election in Vancouver will be dominated by the park board issue. For better or for worse.”
Oh, we plan on it. 🎤🫳
https://www.biv.com/news/commentary/rob-shaw-vancouver-park-board-drama-shows-how-bad-things-have-gotten-with-ndp-11408194
HEADLINE: Vancouver park board drama shows how bad things have gotten with NDP
NDP’s messy handling of the issue signals a deeper breakdown between the province and city
There’s a chill in the air in Vancouver these days, and it’s not just from the fall weather. The relationship between the city and BC NDP government has reached unusually frosty levels.
The latest temperature drop came Monday when Housing Minister Christine Boyle abruptly announced she was scrapping legislation to let Mayor Ken Sim eliminate the city’s park board.
“The city has more work to do clarifying their intended direction,” Boyle proclaimed late in the day on social media.
Vancouver officials were furious.
The city had already waited more than two years for Premier David Eby to agree to crack open the Vancouver Charter. Eby kept dismissing the issue of eliminating the province’s only municipal park board as unimportant.
Boyle then threw a curveball into the final bill, requiring a referendum on the park board’s future before Sim’s ABC majority party could act. After the mayor complained publicly, Boyle went further, yanking back the entire bill and pinning the blame on Vancouver.
“The province failed to consult with local First Nations and the City of Vancouver ahead of the introduction of this legislation in its current form,” Sim replied to the minister on social media.
“Our position has been clear all along. It’s the responsibility of the minister to properly engage on her own legislation.”
Caught in the middle are local First Nations, who say they haven’t been kept in the loop on the ongoing back-and-forth, legislation or amendments between the city and province.
This is not how provincial legislation usually works. It is, comparatively speaking, a gong show.
All eyes are on Boyle over how the situation has devolved. She used to sit on Vancouver council and spar with Sim as a member of an opposing party. Now, a year later, she’s a provincial cabinet minister with the power to make his life difficult.
Is she exacting revenge? It’s an open question, as the file tilted sideways in unusually combative ways over the last month.
Sim has said the city wasn’t consulted about the province’s legislation before it was tabled Oct. 9. That’s surprising considering the bill only affects one municipality, and is in response to Vancouver’s very specific request. But New Democrats appeared to take a ‘we know better’ approach to drafting, plunking the bill down onto the floor of the house on a random day, sight unseen from Vancouver.
Inside the bill was a line that would have allowed future city councils to transfer park land to First Nations with a unanimous council vote and not a referendum.
Sim’s officials spent several days trying to get Boyle’s officials to remove the line. Boyle ultimately refused. So Sim went public with a statement saying he would not support the bill. And then within 24 hours the premier reversed course to say he’d take the line out.
“We’ve done our best to bring it forward and to meet the various and sundry requests of the mayor and council, as well as the administration of the City of Vancouver,” said Eby, skipping over two years of delays and a crafted-in-secret drafting approach.
“If he doesn’t want that section in the bill, that’s okay with me.”
New Democrats blamed the city for wanting the First Nations line in the first place, producing an email from Vancouver’s former chief administrative officer that indicated the city would support such a move. The city countered by saying council never voted to endorse that approach. And so it went.
It’s clear, at this point, the working relationship between the NDP government and the City of Vancouver is at its lowest point in a decade. We haven’t seen a public spat like this since ex-New Democrat-turned-mayor Gregor Robertson and Liberal premier Christy Clark duked it out over housing and social policies.
What’s less clear is who benefits.
Does the Eby administration have a mayoral candidate it intends to back against Sim in next year’s election? Is Eby’s office out to jam Sim to make him look ineffectual to voters? Is this mostly Boyle exacting revenge against Sim for a year on council in which they clashed? Is Sim picking a fight with the province to bolster his own election chances?
Whatever this is, it’s a mess.
And now next year’s municipal election in Vancouver will be dominated by the park board issue. For better or for worse.
Rob Shaw has spent more than 17 years covering B.C. politics, now reporting for CHEK News and writing for The Orca/BIV. He is the co-author of the national bestselling book A Matter of Confidence, host of the weekly podcast Political Capital, and a regular guest on CBC Radio.
NDP’s messy handling of the issue signals a deeper breakdown between the province and city