25/06/2026
Bannockburn World Cup Round #1
Hugh Despenser 'the Younger' (ENG) vs James Douglas (SCO)
Hugh Despenser 'the Younger' was the son and namesake of an English lord with a long history of service to King Edward I. The younger Hugh Despenser also enjoyed a close personal relationship with Edward II, whose niece Eleanor de Clare he married in 1306. His father also vigorously defended Edward II's familiar Sir Piers Gaveston during the crisis that cost Gaveston his life in 1312, which likely helped ingratiate both Despensers with Edward. It was the opinion of a contemporary chronicler at Lanercost Priory that Despenser was 'the King of England's right eye and, after the death of Piers de Gaveston, his chief counsellor'. He accompanied Edward II on the campaign that ended in disaster at Bannockburn, being granted lands forfeited by Sir John Graham and Bruce's nephew Sir Thomas Randolph on the way north. Despenser escaped the battlefield on 24 June, probably in King Edward's entourage, and actually benefited from the disaster, since his brother-in-law Gilbert de Clare, earl of Gloucester, had been killed there without heirs. In the years that followed, Despenser vastly increased his personal landed interests, both through acquisition of former Clare lands and grants from the king. His acquisitive approach to lordship helped provoke an outright baronial rebellion from 1321-1322, but after this ended - no thanks to either Despenser or the king - in the defeat of the rebels, King Edward apparently felt free to lavish unrestrained patronage on his latest favourite. However, the Despensers used their newfound influence to alienate Edward's queen Isabella, who responded by orchestrating both their and her husband's downfall. Having secured custody of her son - the future Edward III - and recruited a mercenary army on the Continent, Isabella effectively invaded England in late 1326 and seized control of the government. The younger Despenser was hanged, drawn, and quartered at Hereford (pictured) and his remains displayed at Bristol, Dover, York, and Newcastle.
James Douglas is one of the most famous - and fearsome - figures from the First War of Scottish Independence. His father had been a relatively minor, thuggish laird from Lanarkshire whose lands had been forfeited by Edward I for fighting against the English crown after 1296. Left effectively landless and still a minor, Douglas (and probably his half-brothers Archibald and Hugh) may have fled to France, possibly returning to Scotland c. 1304 in the household of William Lamberton, Bishop of St Andrews. By the time Robert Bruce became King of Scots in 1306, Douglas may have been serving as a valet to Sir Henry Sinclair (or, less likely, Sir Robert Keith). After experimenting with the prospect of reaching an agreement with the English crown over his lost lands, by 1307 Douglas had come out in favour of King Robert I, and in the years that followed he carved out a fearsome reputation as one of the most dangerous and capable war leaders among the Bruce Scots. In February 1314, Douglas and his followers captured Roxburgh Castle by ruse, weakening the English administration in Scotland ahead of the Bannockburn campaign. On 24 June, he was personally knighted by King Robert ahead of the second day of fighting at Bannockburn. After 1314, Douglas became one of King Robert's closest councillors as well as continuing his vigorous and successful military career. His rise to prominence during this period was no doubt helped by the fact that his cousin Walter Stewart was now the king's brother-in-law. But it difficult to explain the remarkable favour shown to Douglas by Bruce without supposing they were also good friends, as the later Scottish poet John Barbour claims. By the end of the reign, Douglas was one of the great magnates of the kingdom - albeit having never been given the title 'earl' - and following King Robert's death Douglas carried the king's heart on crusade to what is now Spain. His death in this last, desperate act of service to his late lord cemented Douglas's chivalric reputation at home and abroad. He is alternately remembered as 'the Black Douglas' and 'the Good Sir James', in both cases for his formidable martial prowess.
Hit Like to vote for Despenser, hit Heart (of course) to vote for Douglas!