27/06/2026
When solutions are not yet known... we must first define the system, the boundaries, and the relationships between ecosystems. We need a picture.
How do we get past the shock and horror that often paralyses us when we come to understand scientist's warnings about the irreversible damage Nature is sustaining ?
How do we deal with fear about the future in ways that don't retract into disbelief and denial?
How can we manage anger and blame, which are rather natural responses when things seem to be spiraling out of control?
How can we process our guilt that our needs, conveniences and entertainments have contributed greatly to the suffering of people in other places, degradation of wild and beautiful places, and risks to our own children and grandchildren and great grandchildren?
How can we accept the realities of the situation, and accelerate productive transformation?
How do we reframe the predicaments and paradoxes created by the Industrial Revolution - into new ways of understanding the problems of change for good of all - and thus generate the imense amount of ingenuity we will need to emerge, learn, create, design, build, regenerate, manage and thrive through the transition of whole systems to downshift the unsustainable energy and material flows which are currently 'normal'?
I can't tell you everything we have learned in this Facebook post, but I can start with the first step.
The Transition Engineeirng Lab is charged with answering the question "How do we proceed when solutions are not known?"
The first rule of engineering is "Define the problem you must solve." Here is the first massive challenge, because the problems of downshifting unsustainable energy and materials consumption are
- Complex, with interconnecting aspects that are hard to understand.
- Messy, with competing interests and champions of various technologies, policies, and plans that don't bring resolution.
- Involve people with perspectives, including not wanting to change.
- Do not have established processes or the needed information.
In order to define a problem in a way that makes it understandable and workable, we have to define the system and draw the system boundary.
Applying this logic, the Transition Engineering Lab contributed the first breakthrough - an applied systems thinking framework that lets us and stakeholders frame up the predicament as an exploration of interconnected ecosystems. The Ecosystems Framing Process uses the drawing here to identify the primary ecosystem, the interrelations with other ecosystems, and intersections and reliances on infrastructures, supplies, reguations, markets and the environments. It is one of the first process tools in our new Transition Engineering Lab Handbook.
Try it for yourself!