29/04/2025
There was always going to be one way that selling passports would end up: BADLY.
That is exactly what happened today when the EU Court decided that selling passports is illegal.
For me, this was obvious from the start when the scheme to sell our citizenship was first presented by the former disgraced Prime Minister, Joseph Muscat, in 2013. As Opposition Leader at the time, I had immediately made our position clear: selling our nationality is just not on. It is morally wrong, it is politically wrong and it is legally wrong. And it is also a recipe for corruption.
Today, the EU Court confirmed that when we sell our passport we are also selling EU citizenship, which gives EU rights in another 26 EU countries. The right to grant citizenship comes with the responsibility of being loyal with those countries and not simply sell their common EU citizenship for money, like a commercial transaction. It is disloyal and breaches the mutual trust that there should be among EU countries.
We said this from the start. But the point is not who was right, but rather how we can now fix yet another Labour mess. Here's how:
First, the word of the Court must be obeyed and the current scheme must be ended - otherwise we risk significant daily fines.
Secondly, someone must carry political responsibility for the political mistakes that have been committed by a stubborn government that had been warned about this from the very start but persisted in its wrong policy.
Thirdly, we need fresh ideas to put our economy on the path of sustainable long-term growth. This is where the genius of government lies, not from taking short cuts to make a quick buck, at the cost of legality, of reputational risk and sustainability. And yes, there can be investment schemes, if planned in the right way.
Today's landmark judgment is a massive legal breakthrough, also for other EU countries: selling citizenship is not just morally wrong - it is also legally wrong. But as usual, the Labour government has to be dragged screaming to get it to do the right thing.
Partit Nazzjonalista Repubblika Times of Malta
NGOs: 'Will close one door to corrupt actors buying their way into EU'; Developers disappointed