27/08/2026
Today we celebrate the life and service of Constable James Dorgan, who died performing his duty 105 years ago. His death remains the only unsolved police officer murder case. Moe mai rā James, you will always be remembered.
Name & rank: Constable James DORGAN
Police number: 1764
Born: 26 January 1884
Years in Police: nine
Died: Murdered 27 August 1921
Age: 37
Married with three children
James’ story:
James Dorgan was born in Ireland. He moved to New Zealand as a young man and worked as a farm labourer before joining the New Zealand Police in 1912, aged 28. He briefly served in Christchurch before transferring to Timaru, where he was stationed from 1913 until his death in 1921. Constable Dorgan married Agnes Mary 'Minnie' Dorgan in 1915, and he and his wife had three children.
On the night of 26 August 1921, Constable Dorgan was on beat patrol along with two other officers. Constables Christopher and Dorgan each walked part of the main street, while Constable McCullough patrolled the back street of the town. At 00:30 on 27 August, Constable Christopher discovered that the glass in the doors of T & J Thomson's drapery and clothing shop had been covered with paper. Light could be seen glowing through the gaps. He signalled to Constable Dorgan that a robbery was in progress. The two officers tried the doors but found them locked. Constable Christopher went to the shop owner's nearby house to get the keys, leaving Constable Dorgan to guard the shop. Suddenly, shots rang out. Christopher ran back to find Dorgan staggering out from behind the shop, saying:
“He fired four shots at me and ran up the back. Get me a drink, I'm done, I'm done!”
A doctor was called to the scene but it was already too late. Constable Dorgan had been shot in the chest, and he died shortly after the doctor arrived.
Constable Dorgan's funeral was one of the largest seen in Timaru at that time. Shops closed to allow their owners to attend the popular constable's funeral.
It is possible that the offender had hidden on a balcony until the owner closed the shop. When disturbed by the Police officers, the offender had abandoned two bags of clothing taken from Thomson's store. Police took 70 sets of fingerprints and closely questioned several suspects in the search for the officer's killer. Despite extensive investigations, the murder of Constable Dorgan remains unsolved.