11/30/2025
We are now rumbling into the holiday season. I hope all readers had a joyful Thanksgiving with family and friends.
I expect that posting on this page will be a bit slower for the holiday month, but we wanted to get a note out on where things stand heading into winter.
The mayor released a formal letter about what the city is doing about vehicular noise. We are clearly in support of the efforts from the city and APD to give out more citations. Their primary approach appears to be centered on modified exhaust systems. The mayor and the city stopped well short of a coordinated campaign against noise, which was the goal we pressed for at the public forum. At the same time, we recognize that the pressure from our group has put this issue front and center for city leadership. I know from meetings I had on noise going back into 2024 that this issue would never have gotten this level of attention from the city if not for our activist campaign.
There have been many comments on this page and on the statements by the mayor. Our last post on noise enforcement had an engagement of >45k. One point that comes up repeatedly, and functions as a zombie argument, is something like this:
"It’s downtown Appleton… there’s gonna be noise🤣🤣"
All the people who have chosen to live downtown know and love its liveliness. We've expressed that many times. People love being able to walk to the farmers markets or to concerts during Mile of Music. People expect cars along College Ave. It appears to be difficult to imagine for some people who live at a distance, but the noise in the past few years has gotten out of hand and goes beyond what people should have to live with.
I struggle with the notion that anyone could respond to this real problem by saying: "well, those people should move away!" Such a response shows a lack of imagination as well as a profound lack of civic empathy. Follow out that logic to its impossible vision: these historic neighborhoods should be abandoned by anyone who doesn't like living with window rattling noise. These are long established and close-knit neighborhoods! These are the building blocks of a successful city!
Then add to this the continuing fact that the downtown is becoming home to more and more apartments. Right now 400+ residences have been built along College Ave, and hundreds more are on the way in the next two years. This is a choice the city is making based on its own development plans, and the result is that College Ave and its feeder streets must become livable spaces. The writing is on the wall in this regard.
Excessive vehicular noise is not an issue that is going away. The heated debate on our page--evident as well on the mayor's letter to the community--show that this issue cuts into real divisions in our community and American society, especially divisions that have opened up post Covid. It is our view that abandoning the field to claims of absolute liberty are not the path to livable communities or for preserving quality of life.
The notions we are defending were at one point widely and generally recognized within a curriculum of community civics. I have been browsing older textbooks on this topic. Here is one section near the opening of such a book, expressed in a fashion that makes it sound like this is hardly a point that could be debated:
"Another result [of community interdependence] is that it places certain restrictions upon our liberty... If any member of the community had absolute liberty to do as he pleased, he would soon interfere with the rights of others. Then what would become of the 'equality' which the Declaration proclaims? Equal liberty for all is the aim of democracy, and this can be obtained only when each acts with full regard for the rights of others."
Ours is a movement that is pressing for limitations on noise and aggressive driving when it credibly and clearly corrodes the quality of life of residents. This is an obvious task for the city to take up.