08/20/2026
Defendant Joseph Kaynen Gurley has been found Guilty of Murder and Attempted Murder after a four day trial in Baldwin County Circuit Court. The Defendant shot and killed J. Matthews Bonnell and then attempted to kill Michael Rohe immediately after at the Audubon Apartments off County Road 64 in Daphne on March 31, 2024. The Defendant fled the scene and was on the run for over 48 hours. He was ultimately apprehended hiding in the woods in Washington County.
Patrick Doggett with the Baldwin County District Attorney’s Office prosecuted the case to the jury with help from Jodee Crites, certified victim service officer and trial coordinator. Daphne Police Department thoroughly investigated this incident with the leadership of Lt. Jason Lazzari. The Baldwin County Sheriff’s Office and the Unites States Marshall’s also aided in the investigation and apprehension of the Defendant.
Sentencing is set for October 13, 2026, at 11am in front of the Honorable Judge Ashley Siebert. The Defendant, due to his prior history, will be sentenced to Life in Prison or Life in Prison without the possibility of parole.