06/10/2026
MYRTLE BEACH MAN SENTENCED TO PRISON IN FATAL DUI CRASH
CONWAY, SOUTH CAROLINA – Fifteenth Circuit Solicitor Jimmy Richardson announced that on Tuesday, June 9, 2026, a Myrtle Beach man pleaded guilty to felony driving under the influence resulting in death.
Michael Wagner, 38, of Myrtle Beach, pleaded guilty Tuesday to felony DUI resulting in death, which is a violent and serious offense, said Brandon Lanier, the assistant solicitor who prosecuted the case for the 15th Circuit Solicitor’s Office.
The Honorable Circuit Court Judge Michael Nettles presided over the hearing and sentenced Wagner to 10 years in prison. Wagner must serve at least 85 percent of his sentence before he is eligible for supervised release. Wagner will have one strike under South Carolina’s three-strike law, which makes him eligible to be sentenced to life without parole, should he ever be convicted of two other serious offenses.
The charges stemmed from a deadly crash that occurred about 1:40 p.m. on May 19, 2025, in the Myrtle Beach area when Wagner, driving with a 0.21 blood alcohol concentration, was speeding down S.C. 31 southbound in a Dodge 3500 work van. Wagner was headed home from a job when he failed to maintain his lane and struck the back of the victim’s sedan, causing it to flip and crash into the wooded area off the side of the road near the mile 14 marker.
The victim, Richard “Mike” Nicholson, 84, of Murrells Inlet, died instantly. Nicholson, a Navy veteran, spent 30 years working for the Federal Government in a variety of leadership roles, including at the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office and the Department of Homeland Security.
Wagner drove away from the scene but was found passed out in a convenience store parking lot, with open containers in his vehicle, by South Carolina Highway Patrol Troopers.
The South Carolina Highway Patrol Multi-disciplinary Accident Investigation Team (MAIT) investigated the crash and reconstructed the crash, in large part due to the dash camera of a motorist, which recorded the entire event.
“On Tuesday, June 9th, 2026, Michael Wagner was the second person to plead to felony DUI resulting in death and receive a decade-long sentence, in a case all too familiar to the other,” Lanier said. “This deadly crash happened just over a month after the previous case, both defendants were grossly impaired before noon, and both killed remarkably distinguished men, who were simply trying to get home. The victim in this case, Mr. Nicholson, was a public servant who dedicated his entire life to this country. His family is expectedly devastated by his loss. The sentence is only a slight reprieve. Our hope is that this case will serve as a reminder to those who use alcohol, and to those who sell it, that drinking and driving is never the right choice. We appreciate the Highway Patrol for their work on this case.”