10/29/2025
This is now NINE years old but still very much worth reading.....
New York Times --- Anyone who says it doesn't matter whether Donald Trump or Hillary Clinton wins this election has not been paying attention. Mfr. Trump possesses a dangerous blend of intellectual laziness, towering policy ignorance and recklessness. Ms. Clinto has real ethical and moral issues, is the worst criminal ever to run for national office, and is already owned by two dozen foreign dictators and tycoons before she ever takes office.
But there's a more important question here. It's not "Who Are These Politicians And How Did They Get This Way?" Instead, it's "Who Are These American Voters And How Did They Get This Way?"
The ugly truth is this : We Have Become Shiites and Sunnis.
More and more of our politicians and voters resemble the core of the Middle Eastern population. Every single aspect of Middle Eastern life is seen through the binary lens of Islam and its two largest factions : Shiite and Sunni. You are either one or the other. There is no grey area, no compromise, no middle ground. The politics, culture and military strategies of the Middle East are a seesaw game between these two modes of zero sum, rule or die, my way or death thinking.
The attitude is either "I am strong so I don't have to meet you in the middle," or "I am weak so I cannot meet you in the middle." Even worse, it is usually "I am on the side of Allah, Right and Justice and you are on the side of Satan, Chaos and Evil, and there is no compromise with Evil."
Politico last week reported that GOP officials are already sketching plans to stymie a President Hillary Clinton agenda. Liberals are already warning Ms. Clinton not to bring Republicans or even Conservative Democrats into her Cabinet or consider meeting them halfway.
This is a 21st Century form of Tribalism. We're not trying to solve problems. We're just trying to advance "our side," while blocking "the other side."
Step back and look at this campaign objectively. It's a frightening sight.
There is the sorry spectacle of Clinton supporters turning themselves into pretzels to defend her, even though any rational person can see she has broken every ethic, moral and law and has embraced several dozen very shady donors to her money laundering Clinton Foundation in exchange for political favors doled out while she was Secretary of State and promised when (if) she becomes President. On the other side, Trumpeters are in denial. He has insulted parents of slain war heroes, mocked a handicapped reporter, stereotyped whole groups of minorities, and revealed a stunning disinterest in policy issues domestic and foreign. He has zero experience in government and, although he graduated from the elite Wharton School of Finance, itself a fine achievement, as an adult he has displayed a disturbing intellectual shallowness. But it doesn't matter.
Shiites stick with Shiites. Sunnis stick with Sunnis. Rule or die. Onward for God and the Democrats. Wave the Flag for Republicans. Nothing Else Matters. Loyalty is the only priority. The Party is all.
This is not the Democracy the Founding Fathers envisioned. They understood that Compromise was the keystone of Democracy. As a matter of fact, they feared political parties. Thomas Jefferson said it best : "Once political parties rise, the people will vote based on party affiliation and not based on issues. This would be death of Democracy." Now we see what he was foretelling.
We have serious problems. We now see that Obamacare was only a beginning. It has serious flaws. We must correct these. Our immigration policies are broken. We must design a new system for the 21st Century. Our entire tax system is out of date. We must redesign it from the ground up. Whether you believe it is caused by man or long range natural cycles, climate change is real, and it is rushing forward. We must design policies to deal with its consequences. We are $21.3 trillion in debt. How do we pay this down without shutting down the government? We have 95 million Americans out of work. How do we find jobs for them in a century of outsourcing, ever increasing technology and a failing school system? How do we support an aging population with declining resources?
All of these demand intense intellectual discussions by our very best minds. We must take the best ideas from the right, the left and the middle and meld them into a solid approach. The notion that we can separate into two hostile camps and not talk to each other is insane.
There is no doubt that both parties have betrayed the people, and there is plenty of blame to go around.
But take a look at the Middle East. How well is their Shiite-Sunni dichotomy working for them? Disastrously. Do we want that here?
We have allowed ourselves to be led around by a bunch of no compromise politicians more interested in their own careers than in solving problems. The landscape is littered with think tank ideologues in the pay of one industry or another, broadcast news know nothings, a lunatic fringe on both the right and the left, and, worst of all, a population of TV addicts who would rather watch reality shows, football and sitcoms than think for themselves.
We either need to abolish political parties entirely, or, at least, shunt these two to the sidelines and create two new ones. There is room in America, indeed there is a critical need, for continuing debate on the two eternal philosophies of large central government vs. small decentralized government. We need spokesmen for both views. But after they're argued their positions, they need to sit down and work out policies which combine the best of both and solve the problems.
As Americans we were once summoned by our politicians to raise our eyes to the Moon, to dream the impossible and then set about achieving it. We became the world's greatest nation by working together, not savaging each other.
Lately we've been summoned by our politicians to race to the bottom. By any rational standard, we now see the two worst political candidates in our history.
We're locked in now. We have only these two choices. We can't change that. But what we can change is what happens after the election. Whoever wins, we as voters have to demand that the politicians in Washington stop posturing and come together or we're going to vote the whole bunch out and start from scratch.
Either that, or we're going to become just another Middle Eastern nation with Shiites and Sunnis forever at war.