08/25/2026
August 25, 1862: The Battle of Dover
After Shiloh and the controversial surrender at Clarksville, the question hanging over the 71st Ohio Volunteer Infantry was unavoidable: When the next demand for surrender came, what would the remaining soldiers choose to do?
On August 25, 1862, at Dover, they faced that moment.
A week after taking Clarksville, Confederate officers Thomas Woodward and Adam “Stovepipe” Johnson moved again through the region with roughly 900 men—far outnumbering the 160 soldiers of the 71st holding Dover. Major James Hart commanded the detachment, positioned behind earthworks on the main hill and supported by two unreliable cannons captured at Fort Donelson. Hart requested help from the 5th Iowa Cavalry at Fort Henry, but until reinforcements arrived, the Ohioans stood alone.
Around 1:30 p.m., Woodward’s forces approached Dover, some wearing civilian clothing that allowed them to surprise and capture pickets along the roads. Woodward demanded the Union soldiers surrender. Hart refused. After reviewing their situation, Hart and his officers agreed they could hold and prepared to fight.
To remove hiding places near their position, the 71st set fire to several buildings. As smoke filled the streets, Woodward’s cavalry advanced, pushing into town from multiple directions. The defenders held firm, firing from their fortified position and stopping each attempt to break through. Woodward’s horse was shot during the attack, and he escaped on foot. After about thirty minutes of fighting, the Confederates withdrew. Remarkably, the 71st reported no killed or wounded.
The 5th Iowa Cavalry arrived later that evening and pursued Woodward the next morning. In September, Woodward left Clarksville as United States forces—including the 71st—moved in. The men at Dover had met the question that had followed them for months and answered it in full view of their commanders, their community, and the nation.
Chaplain A. L. McKinney later shared the detachment’s experience with a local newspaper, offering a contemporary view of what the battle meant to those who fought it:
“You are fully aware of the odium that has been attached—we think unjustly—to the Seventy first regiment Ohio volunteer infantry…. I thank God that this detachment, at least, has flung that foul disgrace from its shoulders—washed the stain of imputed cowardice from its skirts in the blood of the enemy.”
Image caption: Newspaper report from the New York Tribune on the August 25, 1862, Battle of Dover.
Image is courtesy of Library of Congress, Chronicling America.