08/30/2026
📖 Did you know the town of Guffey was named after a Pennsylvania oilman?
Many people know Guffey for its quirky charm and mountain scenery, but the story behind its name reaches far beyond Park County. This fascinating post from Colorado Mountain Distillers explores the life of James McClurg Guffey and how his name became part of Colorado history.
We love seeing local businesses help share the stories that make our communities so unique. Take a look at the original post below to learn more!
STORIES FROM GUFFEY — NO. 3
THE MAN BEHIND THE NAME: JAMES McCLURG GUFFEY
Long before Texans became such a familiar part of life in Guffey, the man whose name our town carries had already built a reputation far beyond Colorado.
James McClurg Guffey was a Pennsylvania oilman, investor, entrepreneur and political leader whose business interests stretched across a remarkable part of North America.
By the late nineteenth century, he was involved not only in Pennsylvania oil, but also in natural gas development in Ohio and West Virginia, coal lands in West Virginia, mining interests in Colorado and Idaho, and ventures reaching into Texas, California and Nova Scotia.
In other words, James Guffey was not a small local figure.
He was a man whose money followed opportunity wherever it appeared — oil, gas, coal, gold, silver, railroads and land.
And his influence was not limited to business.
For decades, Guffey was also deeply involved in Pennsylvania politics. He served as Pennsylvania’s representative on the Democratic National Committee beginning in 1897, attended national political conventions, and was remembered at his death in 1930 as a longtime political leader in his home state.
That political history is worth mentioning not because of party politics today, but because it tells us something important about who James Guffey was: He was connected.
He moved comfortably in the worlds of business, finance, transportation, natural resources and government — exactly the kind of influence that mattered enormously during the expansion of the American West.
And that brings his story to Colorado.
In the 1890s, the area surrounding present-day Guffey was part of the Freshwater Mining District, where prospectors and investors hoped the enormous success of nearby Cripple Creek might be repeated.
James McClurg Guffey had interests in that district, and in 1896, the settlement that had first been known as Freshwater and briefly as Idaville took a new name:
Guffey, Colorado.
One interesting piece of local lore says that a nephew of James McClurg Guffey may have donated $500 toward road improvements in Guffey, Colorado, around the time the town took the Guffey name. We have found the story repeated in local histories, but we have not found a primary record that proves exactly who gave the money, what the conditions were, or whether the donation was directly tied to naming the town. For now, we think it is best treated as part of Guffey’s oral and local-history tradition rather than established fact.
But Colorado was only one chapter.
In 1897, another community bearing his name appeared in Idaho, this time connected to railroad development on the Snake River. Contemporary Owyhee County material describes Guffey, Idaho as the terminal point of the Boise, Nampa & Owyhee Railroad, with a railroad bridge completed there that same year.
Then came Texas.
Mining engineer Anthony F. Lucas believed that Spindletop, near Beaumont, concealed an enormous petroleum deposit. Lucas needed financial backing, and James Guffey and his associates helped provide it.
On January 10, 1901, the Lucas well erupted.
The Spindletop gusher helped ignite the great Texas oil boom.
Soon afterward, the J. M. Guffey Petroleum Company was organized to develop those oil interests.
Later that same year, the same group organized the Gulf Refining Company of Texas.
Then, in 1907, those operations were reorganized into the Gulf Oil Corporation. The Texas State Historical Association describes Gulf Oil directly as an expansion of the J. M. Guffey Petroleum Company.
And the Guffey name appeared on the map again.
In 1901, a community south of Beaumont became Guffey, Texas, named for J. M. Guffey shortly after the Spindletop discovery. Its post office remained until 1925, and the community continued for some time after the oil boom faded.
So one Pennsylvania businessman ended up connected to three very different western stories:
Colorado — mining.
Idaho — railroads.
Texas — oil.
And behind all of it was a man whose influence stretched through industry, finance and politics at a time when those worlds were helping shape the American West.
For a little Colorado mountain town, that is one extraordinary name to carry.
Small town. Big stories.
Colorado Mountain Distillers
Guffey, Colorado
Sources: Park County Office of Historic Preservation and Park County historical records; Texas State Historical Association, Handbook of Texas; Owyhee County Idaho historical records; historical and biographical records concerning James McClurg Guffey.
