07/24/2026
Today, Miguel Melendez Torres was found guilty of two counts of murder in the second degree, two counts of armed criminal action, and two counts of attempted robbery in the first degree, following a jury trial.
The Taney County jury found that Torres approached the victims, Rocky McMahan and Krystle Buhl, in the back of the Famous Dave’s parking lot on May 29, 2021, with the purpose of robbing them. During this interaction, Torres shot and killed both of the victims. Rocky was transported to the hospital where he died several hours later, while Krystle was pronounced deceased at the scene.
“I want to extend my sincerest condolences to the loved ones of both Rocky and Krystle. They have been through a lot since 2021, including the mistrial in January. Unfortunately, nothing can bring Rocky and Krystle back, but I hope this conviction provides some sense of justice and comfort as they continue to heal from these losses,” said Taney County Prosecutor, Brad Hughes.
The case was investigated by the Branson Police Department with assistance from the Missouri State Highway Patrol.
The case was tried by Taney County Prosecuting Attorney Brad Hughes with the assistance of Assistant Attorney General Paige Wheeler.
Formal sentencing is set for October 6, 2026, at 1pm at the Taney County Courthouse in Forsyth.