09/06/2022
Dear Friends of the Fort Myers Yacht Basin (FMYB)
Last night we had a very productive meeting addressing our mission to improve the FMYB. Councilmember Lin Bochette attended the meeting and made some excellent suggestions and comments.
The City continues to let the FMYB deteriorate on purpose in hopes that this will convince several council members to vote for Suntex to take over the riverfront. It's to the point that almost no monies are spent on maintenance and the City won't hire a full-time dock manager. FMYB-generated funds are being spent elsewhere on other city departments. The further the City lets the FMYB deteriorate, the easier it might be to convince city council members to vote for Suntex. Those of us who have been around marines for years realize the sunken boat left in the marina for over a month by the City is disgusting and sadly preventable. This is a dangerous and reckless approach by the City that could cause injuries to visitors to the FMYB.
We need to continue to network around the City to tell our story about what is happening to the historic Fort Myers Yacht Basin and how Suntex and other special interests are manipulating decisions concerning the FMYB future.
Here is where we are:
• Mayor Anderson and some city council members want to divest the FMYB to SUNTEX with very few restrictions regarding boat slip rental rates, operating quality, or environmental risks associated with demolishing and rebuilding the facility with new aluminum docks. In return, Suntex is supposed to pay off the FMYB $2.3 debt, a percentage of revenues that could earn the City as much as $700,000 annually and, most importantly, remove the City from the burden of managing the FMYB.
• The Friends of the Fort Myers Yacht Basin community approach is to place the FMYB into a self-funding not-for-profit entity similar to the Edison Ford Estate. Repair the docks as is. In addition, manage the facility properly, including providing good paying jobs, avoiding environmental risk, price gouging by Suntex, and massive overbuilding. This approach could self-fund the FMYB with rental rate increases "only if justified" and available grants to pay off the facility's debt and the City's annual lease payments. Keep the FMYB as a community-owned and operated asset.
• Or
• The Friends of the Fort Myers Yacht Basin encourage the City to vote no on SUNTEX and start negotiations with Safe Harbor Development and compare the two. Safe Harbor Development’s project approach is not to demolish the FMYB, remodel the facility to avoid environmental risk, and facilitate the creation of an FMYB advisory board and listen to them. Also, giving some slip rental fees increase relief to the long-term residents of the FMYB.
However, first, the Mayor and the majority of the City Councilmembers must vote no to Suntex. We need to remind the City Council members, the press, and other citizen groups that there are several serious problems with how the decision was made to divest the FMYB in the first place. Normal procedures for justifying the divesture of such an asset which is worth a minimum of $60 million, have not been followed and include:
Neither the council members nor the public has ever received:
A. A detailed report by a licensed Civil Engineer PE documenting that the FMYB is not in economically repairable condition.
B. An economic evaluation by any independent Economic Development Board or any objective 3d party justifying the City divesting the FMYB.
C. A risk assessment stating that if there are environmental damages from Suntex's demolition approach and the City is found liable, how would this affect property taxes, budget reductions, and bond ratings? It is important to note that outsourcing to Suntex does NOT relieve the City of liability for environmental damages. That responsibility is PERMANENT and exposes the City to lawsuits under the EPA's "joint and several liabilities" policy and history of litigation. The City cannot simply shove the legal liability off on to Suntex by signing a contract.
D. An explanation of why the City has not hired a permanent FMYB manager cut maintenance and upgrade expenses, not enforced dock rules allowing unsafe boats in the facility, and why slip rental rates were not increased " only if justified" to keep up with expenses. Was this done by design to further sell the idea of divesting the FMYB to companies like SUNTEX?
In addition:
• On April 15th, 2022, Councilmembers Lin Bouchette and Darla Bonk voted to narrow the selection down to Suntex and Safe Harbor Development and for the city staff to evaluate both before councilmembers made a final decision. Unfortunately, the City staff declared Suntex the winner without following these instructions.
• The public's financial records state that the FMYB revenues are more than $3 million annually before paying operating expenses of just over $2 million. No details have been available on how these operating costs are being spent. The City is not spending monies on the maintenance and repair of the FMYB. Where is the money going?
• The City has over $ 400 million in debt as of 2019. Much of this City's debt has been caused by developers with political campaign contributions in return for votes on projects. Mayor Anderson and several council members do not fully understand the cost and risk involved.
• Why is the City unwilling to treat the historic FMYB similar to the Edison Ford Estate and separate the facility into a not-for-profit self-funding entity and keep the operations within the community?
• It is the job of the Economic Development Board to conduct an objective analysis of the FMYB operations. Any voting or decision before the completion of an independent financial analysis would be reckless and irresponsible.
Action Plan includes:
Send out letters to the editors with local news
Continue to contact city council members , mostly threw networking
Consider more streetside demonstrations
Continue to work with other citizens groups for awareness of what’s happing
Good luck,
Let’s get to work
Bill Westberry
Listed below is Mayor Anderson's and the council members' contact information.
Mr. Kevin B. Anderson "Will most likely vote for Suntex"
Mayor City of Fort Myers
2200 Second St,
Fort Myers, FL 33901
Phone: 239-321-7020
[email protected]
Mr. Marty Lawing "Does not have a vote"
City Manager of Fort Myers
2200 Second St.
Fort Myers FL, 33901
239-321-7024
[email protected]
Ms. Teresa Watkins Brown
Ward 1 – Councilmember
City of Ft. Myers
2200 Second St,
Fort Myers, FL 33901
Phone: 239-321-7001
[email protected]
Mr. Johnny W. Streets, Jr.
Ward 2 – Councilmember
City of Ft. Myers
2200 Second St,
Fort Myers, FL 33901
239-321-7002
[email protected]
Ms. Terolyn Watson
Ward 3 – Councilmember
City of Ft. Myers
200 Second St.
Fort Myers, Fl 33901
239-321-7003
[email protected]
Mr. Liston "Lin" Bochette
Ward 4 – Councilmember
City of Fort Myers
This is the yacht basins district
City of Ft. Myers
2200 Second St.
Fort Myers, Fl 33901
239-321-7004
[email protected]
Mr. Fred Burson
Ward 5 – Councilmember
City of Ft. Myers
2200 Second St.
Fort Myers, Fl 33901
239-321-7005
[email protected]
Ms. Darla Bonk
Ward 6 – Councilmember
City of Ft. Myers
2200 Second St.
Fort Myers, Fl 33901
239-321-7006
[email protected]