08/31/2016
In June of 1990, the Santa Barbara County Board of Supervisors enacted a Noise Ordinance for "unincorporated" areas (areas such as Isla Vista, that are not part of a city). These meetings took place during the summer, while the student population was away, despite protests from Associated Students and long-term residents.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y0VwrcbX1Wo [first hearing, 1990]
Voting 5-0, the ordinance stops amplified sound after midnight on Friday and Saturday and 10pm the rest of the week. At the second hearing, Michael Boyd and Carmen Lodise, who both spent decades fighting for Isla Vista to obtain true self-governance through efforts at establishing a city, spoke out against this new ordinance.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eik_nc5exEY [second hearing, 1990]
Fast forward 26 years to earlier this month, at a meeting of the Isla Vista Community Network: Ruben Cintron, the new Lieutenant of the Isla Vista Foot Patrol, announced a potential change to this ordinance that would stop music at 10pm on every night. The hearing schedule? September 13th, before UCSB students return :/.
http://dailynexus.com/2016-08-13/evplas-thoughts-on-proposed-noise-ordinance-changes/
On August 16th, Ethan Bertrand and Spencer Brandt, two candidates for the Board of Directors of the soon-to-be-voted-on Isla Vista Community Services District, ran a "town hall" to allow people an opportunity to address some of the officers involved in this decision, including the Sheriff's South County Commander, Kelly Moore.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SEn5cYXA5UE [first town hall, 2016]
At this meeting, attended by numerous local politicians (including both Joan Hartmann and Bruce Porter, the two standing candidates for Third District County Supervisor, neither of whom chose to address the audience), stories were told and arguments were made. Almost no one, though, had kind words for these new restrictions.
http://www.independent.com/news/2016/aug/18/isla-vista-pushes-back-against-proposed-noise-ordi/
The current status is that the hearing before the Board of Supervisors has been postponed. As far as I know, we still are not certain when this will come before the board, but I was told "mid-October" (which could mean a meeting in Santa Maria; I pointed this out, so hopefully they will remember and change this to "late October").
http://dailynexus.com/2016-08-17/foot-patrol-postpones-noise-ordinance-change-in-response-to-community-pushback/
This new set of rules comes in the wake of a similar ordinance that has been put in place in the City of Santa Barbara, which was primarily designed to target students of Santa Barbara City College. One of the arguments is that this change will make the rules in unincorporated areas match the rules in nearby cities and counties.
http://www.independent.com/news/2016/feb/11/city-adopts-new-noise-ordinance/
In turn, these changes in the City of Santa Barbara were patterned after a similar set of rules in the City of San Luis Obispo, where they enacted a noise ordinance and an "unruly gathering" ordinance (which is designed to target larger parties: more than 20 people involving excessive noise, public drunkenness, fights, etc.).
http://mustangnews.net/slo-is-getting-quieter-according-to-law-enforcement/
However, there are important differences. The San Luis Obispo Police Department has a partnership with nearby schools (Cal Poly, Cuesta College, and Allan Hancock College) to fund a Student Neighborhood Assistance Program (or SNAP): fellow students who can hand out warnings (rather than police showing up).
http://mustangnews.net/oh-snap-why-you-may-want-to-keep-it-down-the-next-time-you-turn-up/
In fact, the Santa Barbara Police Department has made a similar partnership with Santa Barbara City College, establishing their own SNAP. SBCC has already pledged $100,000. While there has been some talk of such a program in Isla Vista through a Community Services District, UCSB and the County Sheriff are still waiting.
http://www.thechannels.org/news/2015/11/16/sbcc-gives-100000-to-student-run-community-patrol-program/
That said, many students in SLO have found the new noise ordinance to be unfair, which echos the sentiments of many residents in Isla Vista, not just with the new changes on the table, but with the original ordinance in 1990. In many ways, midnight was already a compromise: now, the County Sheriff wants to renegotiate those terms.
http://mustangnews.net/noise-ordinances/