08/07/2026
FORMER BRADFORD HIGH SCHOOL SUBSTITUTE TEACHER SENTENCED TO PRISON AND ORDERED TO REGISTER AS A S*X OFFENDER
Alexander Poyner, 33 years old, a former Bradford High School substitute teacher, was sentenced today to prison and ordered to register as a s*x offender following his conviction for criminal conduct involving a 15-year-old Bradford High School student.
Poyner was formally charged by the Kenosha County District Attorney’s Office in February 2025 following an investigation into s*xually explicit Instagram communications between Poyner and the 15-year-old student.
Poyner worked as a substitute teacher at Bradford High School in Kenosha. He also worked as a substitute teacher at Nicolet High School and in the West Allis-West Milwaukee School District.
According to the criminal complaint, the messages were exchanged between September and October 2024 and included repeated discussions of s*xual acts, s*xual preferences, bo***ge, submission, buying an African slave, and other s*xually explicit subjects.
Among the communications documented in the criminal complaint, Poyner told the 15-year-old student:
“Too bad yoh straight and too young.”
In another exchange, Poyner demonstrated that he understood the significance of the student’s age, writing:
“Shii I hope it ain’t me, I’m not trying to catch a case but when someone turns 18, the gloves are off. No diddy FR”
When the student asked what Poyner meant, Poyner responded:
“I give a certain graduation gift to those who might want it
So….. right back to you!! LMAO”
The criminal complaint documents additional s*xually explicit conversations between Poyner and the student. In one exchange, Poyner connected his s*xual activity to his work around students, writing:
“NGL some days I really needed that cane, and it was hard to sit down at the desk
I did like standing in front of students knowing I was a nasty ass slt boy for a thug the night before
Made me feel dirty and happy”
In another exchange, Poyner wrote:
“Freak!
I support you
No matter what, I’m freakier
I know it”
He then told the student:
“Try me”
The complaint also documents Poyner discussing a s*xual fe**sh involving “water sports” with the 15-year-old student. Poyner provided hints regarding the meaning of the term and referenced “some R. Jelly s**t,” which the complaint identifies as a reference to R. Kelly.
The criminal complaint also documents a disturbing exchange involving race, slavery, and s*xual activity. Poyner wrote to the 15-year-old student:
“Because your darker or you’re into kinky s**t?
I would FR bought some s*xy fine n***as but set them free
But woulda made they offer could live with me and not be a slave, but gotta give me that Afro dick when I need it. Lmao
I’m terrible
Why am I like this?”
The exchange included Poyner discussing buying an African slave for s*xual purposes and was among the numerous s*xually explicit communications documented in the criminal complaint between Poyner and the 15-year-old student.
The Kenosha County District Attorney’s Office will continue to aggressively prosecute individuals who abuse positions of trust or authority to engage in criminal s*xual misconduct involving children. Protecting our students and holding offenders accountable will remain a priority of this office.
The Kenosha County District Attorney’s Office thanks Kenosha Police Department, whose work resulted in Poyner being held accountable.