09/05/2026
A 28-year-old East Liberty, Ohio man with warrants out of that state was arrested on Sept. 4, 2026, for fleeing from the Sheriff’s Office in an SUV and then broke into several business and residences while continuing to flee on foot. There were no life-threatening injuries reported.
• Brandon Lee May was charged with fleeing and eluding while endangering pedestrians, possession of a fi***rm by a felon during the commission of a felony, burglary while armed, grand theft, resisting arrest with and without violence, and driving with a suspended license.
• A passenger in the suspect vehicle, Anthony Shane Morris, 28, of Islamorada, Florida, was charged with accessory after the fact.
The Sheriff’s Office received reports of a reckless driver in a Dodge SUV at approximately 12:30 p.m. near Mile Marker 83 and attempted a traffic stop after recording it traveling 63 mph in a 45-mph zone. The driver, later identified as May, sped away, fled into a Publix grocery store parking lot, where May continued to drive recklessly, endangering pedestrians. May then exited the SUV and fled on foot, while the passenger, identified as Morris, stayed in the SUV, and switched seats, taking the driver’s seat.
May ran toward a plumbing business and attempted to gain access but was unsuccessful. He then fled to a nearby residence where he stole a fire extinguisher, pulled the pin, but continued to run, and jumped a fence at Avocado Street. May again fled into a residence and then jumped into the Gulfside water. May was successfully shocked with a Taser, after multiple attempts during the chase, and taken into custody. May continued to physically resist Deputies by pulling away and kicking, behavior that continued at Mariners Hospital in Tavernier.
May was then taken to HCA Florida Kendall Hospital due to a broken wrist. He remained at that hospital Saturday morning while in custody of the Sheriff’s Office.
Meanwhile, the Sheriff’s Office found two handguns in the Dodge SUV. Morris initially misidentified May to the Sheriff’s Office. He added they met approximately five days ago. Morris was taken to jail.
May is wanted in Ohio for robbery, battery by strangulation, and violation of probation.