05/25/2026
80 Years Ago, Today:
Magistrate Warren Calhoun Guerry
Berkeley County
End of Watch: May 25, 1946
Warren Calhoun Guerry was born on August 23, 1889, in Jamestown to Josh Robert and Elizabeth A. Guerry. He was raised on the family farm in St. James, Santee Township with seven brothers and three sisters.
Around 1918, Calhoun married Miss Mary Bailey. A son, Warren Allen was born on May 12, 1919, and by 1920 Calhoun was working as a Depot Agent for the railroad. By 1930, Calhoun and Mary had added a son, John C. in 1921, a daughter, Evelyn in 1923, and a son, Cecil in 1926. At that time, Calhoun was running a grocery store and Mary was a clerk there. By 1940, Calhoun was farming again and was also a salesman for Watkins Products.
Calhoun continued farming and began serving as a Magistrate for Berkeley County in around 1942.
On May 25, 1946, while acting as a Magistrate in Berkeley County, Calhoun Guerry arrested Charlie T. Smith for cursing and causing a disturbance at a Jamestown store. Smith was searched and placed in the back seat of Magistrate Guerry’s car while a citizen, Luther Altman rode in the front. As Magistrate Guerry drove to the home of Constable Bailey Gamble, Smith pulled a Boy Scout knife from inside his shoe, reached across the seat, and stabbed Magistrate Guerry in the throat. Altman wrestled the knife away from Smith and held him until Constable Gamble arrived a few minutes later. Magistrate Guerry was taken to the Berkeley County Hospital by Woodrow Finklea and Clarence Ackerman, where he was pronounced dead on arrival. The knife wound had severed his jugular vein. He was fifty-seven years old.
Smith was taken by Constable Gamble to the Berkeley County Jail, and a short time later was transported to the State Penitentiary for safekeeping.
Funeral services for Magistrate Warren Calhoun Guerry were conducted on Wednesday, May 28th at the Jamestown Methodist Church and he was buried in the Jamestown Cemetery. He was survived by his wife, his three sons, his daughter, his seven brothers, and his three sisters. All three of his sons were serving in the United States Armed Forces, at the time of his death.
Sixty-six-year-old Charlie T. Smith was convicted of the murder of Magistrate Calhoun Guerry on Saturday, October 25th, and was sentenced to be electrocuted on November 29th, by Judge Frank Eatmon. Smith had previously served two years for manslaughter in North Carolina.
On Friday, November 29, 1946, Charlie T. Smith became the oldest person to be electrocuted at the SC State Penitentiary. There was no motion for appeal and Smith spent his last nineteen days on death row. When asked if he wanted to make a statement, Smith replied, “I have nothing to say.” State Electrician Sam Cannon pulled the switch and Penitentiary Physician Dr. M. Whitfield Cheatham pronounced Smith dead moments later. No one claimed his body, so Smith was buried in the prison cemetery.
Berkeley County Magistrate Warren Calhoun Guerry was inducted into the South Carolina Law Enforcement Officers Hall of Fame in 1996, never to be forgotten.
Magistrate Guerry’s grandson, Georgetown Deputy Chief of Police C. Spencer Guerry was shot and killed in the line of duty on March 9, 1994.