09/03/2026
Herb Score struck out 245 men as a rookie in 1955, more than any first year pitcher in the history of the game had ever managed. He had just turned 22. ⚾
He was born in Rosedale, on the Queens edge of Long Island, and was hit by a bakery truck at three, which left him in bed for long stretches of childhood. He was sick constantly as a kid. His family later moved to Lake Worth, Florida, and he came out the other side of all that throwing as hard as anyone alive. Cleveland signed him for sixty thousand dollars, and by his second season he had won 20 games and struck out 263, and the Red Sox offered a million dollars in cash to buy him. Cleveland said no.
On May 7, 1957, Gil McDougald of the Yankees hit a line drive back through the middle in the first inning. It struck Score in the right eye. He went down on the mound bleeding from the nose and the eye, and McDougald reached him before anyone else and said afterward that he would walk away from the game entirely if Score lost his sight. Score kept the eye. He missed the rest of that season, and he was never the same pitcher again. 🧢
The convenient story is that the line drive ended him. Score spent decades saying that was not it. He insisted he came back throwing well in 1958 and then hurt his elbow that spring trying to push through a cold wet night in Washington, and that the arm, not the eye, was what actually finished him. He won seventeen more games in the rest of his career and was done at 28.
Then he sat in a Cleveland broadcast booth for thirty four seasons. A whole generation in Ohio knew his voice long before they ever learned what his arm had been.