07/07/2021
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE PART 2: To members of the public. Please share this widely and tag your friends. This post is lengthy in order to lay out the sequence of events that led to the resignation of 15 veteran lifeguards in Ogunquit. We want accountability. The short version is as follows: The interim town manager cut me down and demoted me for trying to increase pay rates and apparently taking up too much of his time, he was content with me stepping away as a result of the demotion, after I rejected the demotion they cooked up infractions against me I wasnโt told about at the meeting to convince the select board a change was needed on short notice, the senior guards did not want to work under the new leadership because of how I was treated, the next day the interim town manager scrambled and came back to me with a new narrative of wanting me to run the beach with Fire Chief as Lifeguard Captain, I asked him not to patronize me and was sent home, all the senior guards resigned, and town administration has been in damage control ever since including saying I was never demoted and quit on the lifeguards over a title change. Please read the full version below if you can and let the media and select board members know the story at [email protected]. We'll take any help we can get. The interim town manager can be contacted via email at [email protected].
We were hoping there would be a path forward to resolve what happened a week ago when the interim town manager set off a chain of events that led to every veteran lifeguard resigning. What led to the abrupt restructuring of the Lifeguard service was a series of attempts to explain to the interim town manager and HR consultant that we had a problem this Summer and werenโt paying enough to pull in veteran guards for more shifts in Ogunquit. I budgeted for and vetted similar numbers over the winter. An elected official recommended going even higher than I ultimately did. After the process to approve pay rates dragged on for several weeks without a meeting about them or clear answers I eventually sent more information and suggested a meeting with the SB chair present in an email Sunday June 27th. I had an up and down history with the interim town manager when he was a police lt. and felt the chair might help facilitate more mutual respect. This upset the interim town manager as he felt the request was in relation to pay rates and budgeting and not the uneasy relationship we had. The next morning the assistant captains and I went to the Fire Station looking for a different perspective on the pay rate situation. We received good feedback from the Fire Fighters. When the Fire Chief arrived, he suggested it might be better for him to talk to the Interim town manager than us. Shortly afterwards I received an email requesting my presence for a meeting at 11:30 am in the interim town managers office.
On Monday June 28th at 11:30 am I went to the interim town managers office with the Fire Chief. He told me he had appointed the Fire Chief as Lifeguard Captain and was demoting me to a Lifeguard with a flat pay rate in what would have been my 9th year as Lifeguard Captain and 20th year with Ogunquit Ocean Rescue. The interim town manager stated that the new Fire Chief/Lifeguard Captain would be appointing assistant captains as he saw fit with no mention of me being a prime candidate or running the beach. This was done callously and without regard for how I would receive the news. After 20 years of working for the town of Ogunquit in a seasonal position that was just demoted back to lifeguard, I could not accept a change that would give all my duties to a Fire Chief to delegate. They were content letting me walk and asked me about the senior guards. Before leaving I questioned why this was happening and was told I did nothing wrong, that it was not retaliation for anything, and that it was going to happen eventually anyway. When I asked why the interim town manager didnโt tell me before the season started or give me warning, he scrambled before saying that he was going to ride out the season but it just wasnโt working out for him. He wanted to change the reporting structure and this move helped him do that. The Fire chief asked me if I would wait for him at the beach and I said yes.
After I left, the interim town manager and Fire Chief had a phone call with the townโs HR consultant to discuss what happened and how to move forward. Instead of waiting until the July 20th SB meeting for the official appointment of the new Lifeguard Captain, the interim town manager decided it had to be done the next day based upon my refusal to accept the demotion and his fear of how the situation might unfold. To justify to the select board that this had to happen with only 24 hours-notice, the interim town manager asked the HR consultant to cook up administrative infractions against me to relay to select board members before the Tuesday meeting. These included my putting new pay rate numbers for the assistant captains on my payroll spreadsheet mistakenly believing they had been approved, and submitting hours for myself for winter administrative work. The latter was approved and completed by the HR consultant herself without any problem communicated to me. Over a month after they happened these issues were inflated to cover for the interim town managers abrupt decision and my refusal to accept. Keep in mind I was never told about these things by the interim town manager. He told me the reasons for the change were his personal preference and nothing else.
After I left his office, I went back to the beach to finish the day and wait for the new Lifeguard Captain/Fire Chief. When he came, he did not tell me he still wanted me to run the beach. He talked in generalities about helping him out along with the two former assistant captains. I was pretty distraught and still trying to digest what just happened with no warning. At one point while I was emotional The Fire Chief asked me to at least give him some tips on how to complete payroll for the week. The Fire chief seemed more concerned about the impact of my leaving on him than what had just happened to me, the 20-year employee whose job he had just taken. I asked him why he accepted my position like this and he had no answer other than that he was a new employee and had to. I stated that I planned to go to the SB meeting after work on Tuesday and resign at the podium with a 3-minute speech. The Fire Chief turned to the two assistant captains to get their phone numbers and later asked to meet them early that evening.
The two assistant captains met with the Fire Chief after work. He told them the pay rates I had been seeking for them were too high, but โif they stuck it out this season, they would do some cool things together in 2022โ. They told him that given what had happened to me earlier in the day they no longer wanted to work for the town of Ogunquit. That same evening, I then received a text from the interim town manager asking if I could meet with him again at 9 am the next day in his office. I received another text in the morning asking me to drop by. I did not respond to either. I wanted to enjoy my last day as a lifeguard with the people I cared about and did not want it ruined by another encounter with a man who says he doesnโt care or have emotions about things. After our workout and while getting ready to go on duty the Fire Chief pulled up and told me the interim town manager wanted to meet with me again in his office. The Fire Chief could or would not tell me why. I said I did not want to go and just wanted to enjoy this last day on the beach with my friends and colleagues. When prodded again I suggested he could send me home for refusing but I would not meet with the interim town manager. After another request I relented on the condition that a former guard and good friend would be allowed to come with me.
In this second meeting on Tuesday the interim town manager tried to behave as if Monday never happened. It was clear that when the two assistant captains spoke of resigning the night before he decided he needed to change his narrative and try to keep me because the original plan blew up. He was worried what I might say at the select board meeting and needed to backtrack from Mondayโs demotion. After starting off the meeting accusing me of telling patrons the Fire Chief canโt swim and campaigning for other guards to leave (both not true), he settled in to pretending they wanted me to stay and run the beach with a different title. If someone punches you in the face and then smiles with their hand extended you donโt shake it. They wanted me to stay on for two weeks to see how I liked the new arrangement, but in reality, this would have been two weeks of me helping the Fire Chief adjust to his new job. Just taking away the administrative portion of my duties alone is still taking away one of the main reasons I was still there. To advocate for the men and women of our department and give us a direct line to elected officials and the public. Something I had done much more effectively and efficiently than any other administrator in the region. A Fire Chief will never put his/her job on the line on the lifeguardโs behalf. This one certainly didnโt do it for me when he willingly took my position after 5 weeks in town. After I called out the interim town managers patronization I was dismissed and told to go home just after 12 pm. Me and my friend took this as my termination.
I walked back to the lifeguard station to finish cleaning out my belongings and the Fire Chief arrived to speak with the assistant captains a 2nd time before I could deliver the news I was dismissed. He spent time with each of them reportedly trying to convince them to stay with various incentives. After originally telling them my proposed pay rates for them were crazy the previous evening, he offered them even more than I make. They both turned down this insult to all of us and the reasons we were there. One of them resigned that evening along with another veteran guard. During the select board meeting the line was delivered once again by the interim town manager that this was done to reduce reports to the town manager. It was not until later in the week did information get out about confidential employee information being involved in the decision to push through the appointment of a new Lifeguard Captain without any vetting or questions about his qualifications. The fact the interim town manager assumed a brand-new Fire Chief was qualified to hold this position shows how little respect exists for the Lifeguard Department and our responsibilities.
The following morning the second assistant captain formally resigned after receiving a third and even higher pay rate offer. Every other veteran guard resigned as well. No one was asked to do so, and on Monday afternoon I went out of my way to tell the entire crew what was happening and to look out for each other and themselves pending the SB meeting on Tuesday. I did not anticipate being dismissed before the SB meeting. The rest of the week, a narrative was spread that I was never demoted and the interim town manager just wanted me to have more time in charge on the beach. The truth is I was removed without cause, notice, or a fair hearing from my Lifeguard Captain Department Head position, and dismissed as a lifeguard the following day. I spoke to this fact in my opening sentence at the SB meeting Tuesday evening.
The only way forward that would return things to normal this year for the lifeguard service and give the paying public the protection they deserve involves 1) the full Lifeguard Captain position being returned to myself or a former assistant captain, 2) pay rates being allocated as was budgeted for, and 3) a public apology to all the lifeguards and community affected by this. This situation was created by town administration. Veteran guards responded as any human being would working under leadership that didnโt respect them and the sacrifices required to continue working this job into their 20's. If we had the staff that was needed to comfortably protect the beach the interim town manager never would have heard from me about pay rates. Morale is not great among those still working and they want this whole thing undone. Many will not return next year if they make it through this one. We need someone to take charge and do the right thing for the public and the employees who put their bodies and lives on the line for Ogunquit. Save Ogunquit Ocean Rescue - Jp Argenti