06/22/2026
The Historic House on the Hill-Scriba's Freedom House
Snippet #3
It was in that year, 1853, that Mr. and Mrs. Robinson relocated to a different farm in Scriba, which included a home partially constructed of stone by an Irish stone mason. It is speculated that Mr. Robinson built the wooden addition to this house, as he was a carpenter by trade. The stone portion of the house still stands. Mr. Robinson and his wife Anna were “quite possibly” involved in the abolitionist movement and have been reputed to have aided in the Underground Railroad. (This house has not been identified as being involved in the Underground Railroad.)
Mr. Robinson and Elizabeth Benton were married on June 16, 1882. Mr. Robinson built this new home, reportedly for his second wife. On the corner of City Line Road and State Route 104, the historic house still stands.
Judith Wellman, of the Oswego County Freedom Trail Project, offered this information in her listing of possible Underground Railroad sites: Mr. Robinson, Af. Am-” first house over the city line on the East Oneida Street State Highway between Oswego and New Haven”, Scheulke 10.
This home is listed on the Town of Scriba’s Historical House listing. The original construction date of this historic home is around 1860, according to Oswego County records. The chain of deeds establishing dates and owners is being researched as of this writing, but what is known is that Thomas Robinson built this house and lived there with his wife, Elizabeth. The next owner is a widow that Mr. Krul worked for, then Frank Krul’s Uncle, then a Krul sister-in-law in 1965, then Frank Krul’s father, then Frank Krul, 1976-2023, and lastly, Mr. Rich Burritt of Locavore@Burritt’s, LLC.
This historic house is at risk of being destroyed. This historian, representatives from the Town of Scriba, and the Scriba Historical Society have conferred together with Mr. Burritt in determining a course for this house preservation. Under the current circumstances, it is not feasible to relocate this house. We are grateful to Mr. Burritt, who continues to contemplate the preservation of this unique, historic piece of Scriba architecture and culture.
Laurie Ann Marrano-Johnson
Town of Scriba Historian