09/07/2026
⚖️ What’s Going On With All the Lawsuits Against the City?
One part of Tuesday’s City Manager Report that I think residents should know about is the number of legal cases currently involving the City of Pasco.
The report lists 11 legal matters, although several are separate cases involving the same development. These aren’t all the same type of lawsuit, and being sued certainly doesn’t mean the City did something wrong. But residents should know what’s happening.
🏗️ Several lawsuits involve development and permitting.
A number involve the Madison Park North development. The developer and the City have been fighting over things like road improvements, transportation impact-fee credits, school-zone improvements, right-of-way requirements and other conditions the City placed on the development. Some of these cases are now in state appellate court or federal court. 2026.09.08 City Manager Report.pdf
Another developer has sued the City over conditions placed on a proposed RV park on Lewis Street, including requirements involving RV spacing, roads, traffic circulation, fire hydrants and other site requirements. 2026.09.08 City Manager Report.pdf
👷 Other lawsuits involve actions by City employees.
One person is seeking damages allegedly resulting from the actions of a City employee while that employee was performing official duties. 2026.09.08 City Manager Report.pdf
Another lawsuit makes much more serious allegations involving a City employee and alleges negligent hiring, training and supervision by the City, along with discrimination and other claims. Again, these are allegations contained in a lawsuit, not established facts. 2026.09.08 City Manager Report.pdf
🚔 There’s also a small-claims case involving Pasco Police.
A man alleges his boat was damaged during a police investigation. The City’s insurer denied his claim, and a small-claims trial is scheduled for September 21. 2026.09.08 City Manager Report.pdf
🐕 The City is also named in an animal-control-related lawsuit along with several other agencies. The lawsuit alleges that reasonable steps weren’t taken to address a known danger to the public. 2026.09.08 City Manager Report.pdf
🎪 And another lawsuit involves an attendee at an event.
The allegation is that reasonable steps weren’t taken to prevent an attendee from being exposed to a hazard. 2026.09.08 City Manager Report.pdf
💰 Here’s the number that really caught my attention.
The City’s insurance/risk information shows something unusual.
Pasco actually had fewer claims than would be expected for a city like ours, 161 claims compared with 225 expected.
But the total amount associated with those claims is much higher than expected.
The report shows about $7.3 million expected compared with approximately $24.6 million actually incurred. 2026.09.08 City Manager Report.pdf
And about $21.9 million of that $24.6 million is associated with Public Safety claims. The report says the majority of that Public Safety amount comes from one claim. 2026.09.08 City Manager Report.pdf
To be clear, $24.6 million “incurred” does not necessarily mean $24.6 million has already been paid out. The report doesn’t tell us how much has actually been paid versus how much represents estimated/reserved exposure.
That’s something I think is worth asking about publicly.
How much of the $24.6 million has actually been paid, how much is currently reserved for outstanding claims, and what impact, if any, is this having on the City’s insurance costs and taxpayers?
Residents deserve to understand the City’s legal and financial exposure, especially when we’re simultaneously having difficult conversations about the City’s budget.