08/13/2026
More composting ideas from our friends at Healthy Pastures, Healthy Horses.
~ Composting horse manure continued... ~
The benefits of composted vs fresh manure. (It's a long-ish post but hard to break up into smaller ones.)
With most subjects, there are separate schools of thought. This is definitely true about utilizing horse manure to benefit pastures. Some are dedicated believers in compost and others like to skip the composting and spread it when fresh. Still others view it as waste but we won't address that here.)
There are merits to both arguments. Let's take a look.
Benefits to composting:
It produces a more lightweight product for spreading.
The volume is reduced considerably, which is significant when one horse can produce 10 tons/yr.
The fragrance is earthy and much more tolerable, especially to neighbors (vs manure piles).
Nutrient release is slower, which may benefit plants.
W**d seed germination rates are much lower than with fresh.
Most bedding (in reasonable amounts) and hay waste composts with manure.
Spreading compost is often easier than spreading fresh manure.
Compost is less likely to create mud than manure.
Proper composting kills parasites and fly larvae.
Compost is gold to gardeners thus there is potential income.
More easily tested for nutrients than daily fresh manure.
Compost builds microbiota which increase numbers in soil, a huge boon to pasture health.
If done appropriately it kills parasitic larvae and eggs (worms)
Benefits to spreading fresh manure:
Avoiding the need for compost bins or structures.
The simplicity of spreading it as soon as it's picked up.
It only needs handling once, not twice.
Manure piles don't need a level(ed) site.
Drawbacks to composting:
The need for a bin of some sort and a system of turning piles.
Some bedding types don't compost well, or at all.
Piles need to be covered so nutrients aren't lost via runoff.
Drainage will have to be considered if not in a covered bin system.
Composting needs at least several weeks to be effective.
Water will have to be added at some point, especially if it's in a covered system.
Can lose up to half of the available nitrogen in manure.
Drawbacks to spreading fresh manure:
The stench may be extreme.
The volume may be more than is easily handled at once.
Horse manure is of the 'hot' type (high in N).
There may be more nutrients than plants can use, thus some are wasted or even detrimental.
W**d and unwanted plant seeds can germinate and create new infestations in pastures.
Can and does spread parasites and diseases to the land and other animals.
May not be legal depending on the watershed and drainage.
It can be detrimental to watershed wee wildlife and may contribute to algae numbers downstream.
Medications, hormones and dewormers may persist in fresh manure.
Animals may avoid areas where fresh manure is spread, often for an entire season.
There is a need to do it more often than with compost due to the sheer volume of it.
Major livestock operations may find it easier to utilize raw manure, especially when liquified. They invest heavily in the equipment and systems to do so efficiently, and the product is usually used for croplands, not for pastures.
Most equine operations are very small, and even though ten tons annually per average-sized horse is a lot of manure, if handled on a daily basis, it doesn't have to be a huge chore.
Cost-share funds and even full grants are often available for building composting systems for small horse properties in the US. We've seen beautiful systems that cost the land steward absolutely nothing except an investment of time. We can contact our soil and water conservation district, extension office, or state ag department if this is of interest.
As you can see, it's not just a matter of personal preference or doing things the way Granddad did. There is logic and reasoning on both sides.
We are huge proponents of composting, if that hasn't been apparent yet. :) After seeing multiple operations utilizing both types of manure treatment, we're convinced that the costs of composting are greatly outweighed by its benefits to our land and our equines.
(Pic courtesy of King County SWCD, WA state)