04/21/2026
Susan raises serious concerns
Dear Members of the Rensselaer County Civil Service Commission,
I hope this message finds you well.
I am writing to formally express my concerns regarding the appointment of Mr. Richard Mooney to the position of Director of Operations within the City of Rensselaer.
As you are aware, the City of Rensselaer is a small municipality with a population of fewer than 10,000 residents. Historically, our City has operated under a structure led by a part-time Mayor elected directly by the voters. This model has served the community since the city's incorporation in 1898, and no previous administration has required or established a position such as Director of Operations, City Manager, or any comparable role. Notably, this position does not exist within the City Charter.
Despite this, Mr. Mooney has been functioning in the capacity of Director of Operations since January 1, 2026, following an appointment by Mayor John DeFrancesco. This occurred prior to any approval by the Common Council and without authorization from the Civil Service Commission. In practice, Mr. Mooney has been performing duties that appear to be executive in nature—many of which seem to directly overlap with, or extend from, the responsibilities of the Mayor.
This situation raises serious concerns. It is difficult to reconcile how an individual can serve in what is clearly an executive role—particularly one aligned with a civil service title—without formal approval, and now under the assertion that he is merely “volunteering.” The concept of volunteering in such a high-level executive capacity, while performing the same duties as a paid civil service position, appears inconsistent with both the intent and the letter of civil service law.
Additionally, this matter carries significant public sentiment. Mr. Mooney has previously been rejected by voters on two separate occasions for elected office. His current role, operating with full access to City Hall and the executive office, gives the appearance of circumventing the will of the residents.
If it is determined that such a position is truly necessary for the operation of the City, I respectfully submit that the proper course of action should involve the residents directly. Given that this role effectively expands the executive function of local government, its creation should be subject to a public referendum. Furthermore, any such position should be filled through a transparent and lawful process that allows for public participation, whether by election or proper civil service procedures.
The events that have unfolded since January 1, 2026 suggest a deviation from established processes and raise important questions about governance, accountability, and adherence to civil service law. The residents of Rensselaer deserve clarity, transparency, and assurance that all actions taken are both lawful and in the best interest of the community.
I respectfully request that the Commission review this matter thoroughly and provide guidance or intervention as appropriate.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
Sincerely,
Susan B.