04/29/2026
After a lengthy investigation by SCSO Investigators Dwayne Frizzell & BR Rutherford along with prosecutors from the District 27 DA’s office. New arrest warrants were issued yesterday. Hopefully we can get this old case closed out and get some closure for the family of this victim.
These Three men are once again charged in a 2016 murder, after confessing just days after the murder took place.
WHO: Michael Snelling, Tyler Leverett and Charles Shamblin
WHAT THE PROBABLE CAUSE AFFIDAVIT SAYS HAPPENED:
-June 21, 2016: Matthew Fagan was reported missing after going hiking near Sallisaw with the 3 men.
-July 1, 2016: Leverett told investigators Snelling killed Matthew during an argument with a hammer, then told the other two, they had to help get rid of the body or they or their families would be next.
-July 11, 2016: Shamblin told investigators Snelling repeatedly hit Matthew and, then made the other two kick and punch Matthew also and help get rid of the body or he'd kill them and their families.
-July 7, 2016: Snelling told investigators Leverett is the one who kept punching Matthew and the other 2 tried to stop it, but Leverett threatened their families and made them hit Matthew and get rid of the body.
-The 3 were arrested and in an jail about a year, but, the case was dismissed in 2017 because Matthew's body was never found, despite several searches.
-November 2, 2024: a hunter found a bone less than a half mile from where Matthew went missing.
-A search was conducted and they found 15 teeth, more bones, pants and fabric and it was sent to the OSBI for DNA testing.
-January 6, 2026: OSBI confirms the remains are Matthew's.
-April 28, 2026: murder and accessory charges re-filed against all three suspects
-These are charges, not convictions.
The Sequoyah County Sheriff’s Office made three arrests connected to a missing hiker.