04/24/2024
** NEW BOOK JUST ADDED! Eleanor & Park **
We had some strong feelings about the Moore County Board of Education's decision earlier this year to remove 4 books from public schools. Here's the backstory, summarized from the 1/18/24 article in The Pilot:
"After a six-month process involving extensive discussions, delays, and significant financial resources, the Moore County Board of Education has reached a decision to remove four books from district libraries. The initiative began when board member Philip Holmes proposed reviewing 14 books due to concerns about their appropriateness for school libraries. Despite Holmes' initial proposal, only nine books were ultimately reviewed, and the board voted 5-2 to remove four titles, falling short of Holmes' original request. The decision sparked debates among board members, with some advocating for strict adherence to committee recommendations while others expressed concerns about procedural fairness and the educational suitability of the materials.
Among the books removed are "The Bluest Eye" by Toni Morrison, "Eleanor and Park" by Rainbow Rowell, "Looking for Alaska" by John Green, and "Crank" by Ellen Hopkins. Despite recommendations from review committees to keep all nine books, the board opted for removal, citing concerns about vulgar content, educational suitability, and age appropriateness. While some members, like Pauline Bruno, expressed moral and ethical dilemmas in their decisions, others, like Stacey Caldwell, deferred to the expertise of educators and the review process. The decision, which incurred nearly $14,000 in expenses, including legal fees and staffing costs, is binding for the next two years, barring any substantially similar challenges during that period."
===
We believe that removing books goes against intellectual freedom by limiting students' access to diverse perspectives, ideas, and information. It also is a form of censorship as it suppresses free expression and violates the students' and parents' rights to access information and ideas.
We understand that removing the books from the public school libraries isn't "banning" per se as the books can be purchased elsewhere, which is why we shall refer to these four books as the "Removed Books Repertoire."
The first book is "Eleanor & Park." School Board Member Pauline Bruno said, "Regarding “Eleanor and Park, this book started off as a beautiful teenage story, nice relationship between a boy and a girl who sit together on the bus, but the more you got into it the language was disgusting. It doesn’t belong in any school, and there is absolutely nothing educational about it.”
We couldn't disagree more! We highly recommend the book for Young Adults and it gets 4.4 out of 5 stars on Amazon and 3.9 on Goodreads.
Here's our summary:
"Eleanor & Park" is a young adult novel by Rainbow Rowell that tells the story of two misfit teenagers, Eleanor and Park, who find solace and love in each other's company amidst the challenges of their turbulent lives. Set in the 1980s, the novel explores themes of love, friendship, family dysfunction, bullying, and societal prejudices.
The story follows the unlikely romance between Eleanor, a quirky and artistic girl from a troubled family background, and Park, a half-Korean boy who struggles with his own insecurities. Despite coming from different social backgrounds and facing opposition from peers and family members, Eleanor and Park form a deep connection through their shared love of comic books and music.
Throughout the novel, the characters grapple with issues of identity, self-acceptance, and the search for belonging. Eleanor struggles with body image issues and the trauma of her abusive home life, while Park navigates cultural identity and the pressure to conform to societal expectations. As their relationship blossoms, they learn valuable lessons about resilience, empathy, and the power of love to transcend social barriers.
Ultimately, "Eleanor & Park" celebrates the beauty of first love and the transformative power of human connection, offering readers a poignant reminder that even in the face of adversity, love has the ability to heal and inspire.