09/05/2019
BRIEFING NOTESON CLIMATE SCIENCE AND CLIMATE CHANGE
What do we mean by climate and climate change?
•Climate is theaverageof weatherover time and across large regions, even the entire planet.Weather is what is happeningin one place at one time.
•Theglobalclimate has always variedformany reasons,such asinteractions between components in the climate system (oceans, atmosphere, ice sheets, etc.):-El Niño, a climatic phenomenon where the surface temperature of the eastern Pacific Ocean warms, affecting the weather worldwide, is an example of this.
•Climate change, on the other hand,occurs because the amount of energy in theentireclimate system is changedwhich affectseach and everycomponentin the system.-Changesin the Earth’s orbit, the energy received from the Sun and the amount of greenhouse gasesin the atmospherecan allcause climate change.
How can humanscauseclimate change?
•Human activitiessuch asburning fossil fuels increasethe amount of CO2and other greenhouse gasesin the atmosphere, enhancingthe natural greenhouse effect. Increasing CO2causesthe planet to heat up.-Ice cores show the concentration of CO2in the atmosphere has increased byat least40% inthelast200 years since the Industrial Revolution. The last time CO2increased this much was over a 6,000 year period as the Earth came out of an ice age,andthe average surface temperature rose by 5C.
•Burning fossil fuels and changes in land use, such asdeforestation,havealtered how much sunlight is reflected back into space(called the albedo).-Small particleslike smoke and dust in the atmosphere (aerosols)canreflect sunlight and affect clouds.-Theimpact this has on the climate is only beginning to become clear, and is expected to feature prominently in the IPCC’s 5thAssessment Report in 2014.
What effects will human activityhave on the climate?
•It will get warmer, but the exactclimatic effects oftherecentdramatic increase in CO2arenot certain.-So farwe have seen an increase of 0.8Cin theaveragesurface temperature of the Earth since 1900,with meltingin the Polar Regionsand more frequentextreme weather.
•Simple calculations and our most complex modelsallagree:if we double CO2we will see an averagewarming of between 2 and4.5C. In context,4.5Cis thedifference between today and the deepest ice-age.
•Models ofthe climate system make varying predictions of future temperatures and other effects of climate change because of two major factors:1.Climate sensitivity. Once the climatebegins to change, the effects of that change canlead tofurther changes (called ‘feedback’). Thismakes exacteffectshard to predict.Soif we double CO2, we cannot know exactly whatthe averageincrease in temperature will be.2.Future emissions. We don’t know how successful we will be in reducing greenhouse gas emissions.
Why does climate change matter?
•Small changes in average temperaturecantranslate to big changes acrossthe planet, leading torising sea levels, more extreme weatherandsomeareas becoming much harder to live in.
•Plants, animals, humans andsocietieshave developedin a climate that has variedonly a little, exceptoverextremely long timescales: we are not adapted to cope withrapid climate change.
Common misconceptionsabout climate change‘Not all scientists thinkman-madeclimate change is real’
The vast majority of climate scientists agree on the fundamentals of human-induced climate change, though there is healthy debate about the extent of changeand what to do about it. Just aswith smoking and lung cancer, the weight of evidence strongly suggests that human factorshave caused andwill cause climate change. All national academies of science agree on the existence of man-made climate change, whilemost scientists who disagree work outside climate science.‘Climategate’ and scientific misconduct:Three independent inquiries into the release of hacked emails from the University of East Anglia, which were used to suggestglobal warming was a scientific conspiracy, recommended greater transparency by UEA but found nothing wrong with the science.
‘The UK has had cold winters and poor summers’
Weather is not climate and we mustlook at averages. It is riskyto jump to conclusions about climate change by looking at small areas like theUK.At the global level,local variations average out and it is easier to make clearstatements. Nonetheless, 7of the10warmest yearsin the UKsince 1910 have occurred between2001& 2012.Extreme weather:Climate change also raises the likelihood ofextreme weather events.For instance, floods which we have come to expect once in 100 years are now likely to be seenonce in 10 yearsandsevere thunder storms are 20% more likely than 20 years ago. This is supported by observations.
‘There has been no global warming since 1998’
1998 was a particularly warm year so is an unfair placeto start measuring recent trends. But every decade since the 1950s has seen warming and 2000-2009 was around 0.15Cwarmer than 1990-1999. Temperaturefluctuates naturally, but the general trend is upwards and it moves in a series of jumps.However, the rate of rise does appear to haveslowed in the last decade and we don’t yet know exactly why.
‘Climate change has happened before’
Variations in the climate have occurred, such as the Medieval Warm Period and Little Ice-Age. There could be various causes, e.g. solar activity.But that does not changethe fact that more CO2willcause warming.‘Warming is causing more CO2, not the other way round’Ice-core recordsdo indeed showthat CO2levels rise when the Earth comesout ofanice-age. However, warming and CO2levels cause each other, soif either happens the other will follow.
‘We’re doomed, and there’s nothing we can do about it’
Some claims about the severity of climate changehave gone beyond hard evidence.For instance, climate change has beenspeculativelylinked to high numbers of deaths, and it has been claimed we are close to catastrophic‘tipping points’. While tipping points are genuine scientific possibilitiesthey are hard to predict with any certainty. Meanwhile, there is much we can do toprepare for and to slow climate change.
‘Climate change will have some good effects’
Small increases in CO2may increase crop yieldsbut larger increaseswill affectwhich crops can grow. Some colder areas will become more pleasant, but such benefits will be outweighed by rising seas, heat and drought.
What does the future hold?
How the climate changes in the future will go beyond what we have already seen and the largest effects will be in temperature-sensitive regions like the poles. Long timespans are needed to let the planet adjust. For instance, if the Greenland ice-sheet completely melts, sea levels will rise by many metres over an unknown length of time. As CO2levels increase, the risks associated with climate change become more serious.
Links to further information
Royal Society publication “Climate change: a summary of the science” published in September 2010. The guide summarises the current scientific evidence on climate change and its drivers, highlighting the areas where the science is well established, where there is still some debate, and where substantial uncertainties remain:
http://royalsociety.org/uploadedFiles/Royal_Society_Content/policy/publications/2010/4294972962.pdf
The Department for Business Innovation and Skills’ (BIS) webpages on climate science including sections: ‘Greenhouse effect’, ‘Human activities’, ‘The world is warming’, ‘Natural factors’, ‘Cause of recent warming’ and ‘Effect of rising greenhouse gas levels’
:http://www.bis.gov.uk/go-science/climatescience
Special report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change(IPCC)on extreme weather and climate change adaptation:
http://www.ipcc-wg2.gov/SREX/images/uploads/SREX-SPMbrochure_FINAL.pdf
FAQ from the IPCC’s 4thassessment report in 2007. The reports intended to assess scientific, technical and socio-economic information concerning climate change, its potential effects, and options for adaptation and mitigation:
http://www.ipcc.ch/pdf/assessment-report/ar4/wg1/ar4-wg1-faqs.pdf
“Explaining extreme events of 2011 from a climate perspective”whichcame as a supplement to the American Meteorological Society’s State of the Climate Report 2011:
http://journals.ametsoc.org/doi/pdf/10.1175/BAMS-D-12-00021.1
Highlights of the American Meteorological Society’s State of the Climate Report 2011:
http://www.climatewatch.noaa.gov/article/2012/state-of-the-climate-in-2011-highlights