09/24/2026
Our office would like to extend our sincere appreciation to Sheriff Michael Chitwood of the Volusia Sheriff's Office and his department for their outstanding work and partnership in bringing Scott Mitchell into custody following the February 3, 2025 double homicide in Binghamton.
The successful apprehension of Mitchell in Daytona Beach was the result of strong collaboration between Law Enforcement agencies across state lines. We are grateful to the deputies and investigators who responded to the information received, located Mitchell, and safely took him into custody.
Our office also extends our appreciation to the Binghamton Police Department and all of the Law Enforcement partners whose efforts contributed to this case.
Thank you to the men and women of the Volusia County Sheriffโs Office for your professionalism, dedication, and commitment to public safety.
Partnerships like this demonstrate what can be accomplished when Law Enforcement agencies work together.
CASE UPDATE: Scott Mitchell, the New York double homicide suspect caught in Daytona Beach last year, has been convicted of all counts in the murders of Daniel McCloe and Marshall VanOven.
Mitchell was found guilty in the Feb. 3, 2025, murders in Binghamton, NY:
Mitchell strangled both men with a rope before hitting them in the back of the head with a wrench in the basement of a home in Binghamton. Mitchell then took both bodies, stripped them of their clothes, and put them into trash cans in his garage.
After the murders, Mitchell fled to Florida. We partnered with Binghamton PD on posting a $10,000 reward for information leading to his capture. On Feb. 12, we got a tip about a sighting in Daytona Beach, and deputies arrested Mitchell without incident. The caller received $10,000. Mitchell is facing life in prison at sentencing.