06/29/2026
The Providence Journal: Washington is not the source of Rhode Island’s fiscal woes | Opinion
Rep. Michael Chippendale Guest columnist
June 28, 2026, 6:06 a.m. ET
I read the opinion piece by House Speaker Christopher Blazejewski and Majority Leader Katherine Kazarian ("New state budget built to support, protect RI families," Commentary, June 21). They are friends and colleagues – I like them both and respect their concern for Rhode Island.
But respect does not require agreement, and friendship does not require silence when the argument offered to Rhode Islanders is wrong.
Their claim is that Rhode Island’s $15.2 billion budget is a defensive response to “devastating” policies from Washington. They blame HR-1 and the Trump administration for putting Rhode Island in difficulty.
That may be politically effective in cobalt blue Rhode Island – but it is not honest.
Rhode Island’s budget is not bloated because of Donald Trump. Our dependence on federal money did not begin with HR-1. Focus on our spending habits did not suddenly appear because Washington started asking harder questions about eligibility, compliance, and accountability.
Democratic supermajorities have governed this state for generations. From Carter to Reagan, Bush, Clinton, Bush, Obama, Trump, Biden, and Trump again, Rhode Island leaders kept expanding government, dependence, costs, and excuses when the math stopped working.
For decades, Rhode Island treated federal money as guaranteed income instead of taxpayer money sent with conditions. Federal dollars are not free. They come from taxpayers across the country, including Rhode Islanders, and are subject to federal rules.
Rhode Island understands this when it places conditions on municipalities. State leaders call that accountability. But when Washington places conditions on Rhode Island, suddenly it is cruelty? That is simplistic.
HR-1 is not the cause of this budget. It is the excuse used to justify it. It gives progressive leaders a villain and lets them avoid a harder truth: Rhode Island is vulnerable because Rhode Island chose dependence on federal funding.
That dependence is not compassion. It is weakness, and it is destroying our state.
No state can tax, spend, borrow, subsidize, and federally backfill its way into prosperity. Yet that is Rhode Island’s model. We expand programs, layer mandates, drive up basic costs, then offer another program, subsidy, bond, tax increase, and promise. That is not solving unaffordability - it is feeding it.
Their outrage that Washington expects states to ensure Medicaid and other federal benefits are limited to people who meet eligibility rules is revealing. Whether the issue is income, residency, work status, citizenship, immigration status, or compliance, eligibility should matter. The United States is charitable, but not a charity.
Medicaid is not a blank check, slush fund, or entitlement for anyone who fails to meet requirements. Asking states to verify eligibility and direct benefits to the legally entitled is stewardship of public money.
The real disagreement is ideological. Progressives believe the answer to nearly every problem is more spending, redistribution, central planning, and higher taxes on someone else. When that fails, they find a villain. Right now, the villain is President Trump.
But Trump did not create Rhode Island’s underperforming schools, unaffordable housing, energy policies, road/bridge decay, federal dependence, or budget growth workers cannot keep up with. Those are Democratic failures, built year after year by one-party leaders.
Now the majority party is doubling down with a tax on higher earners, pretending it will only affect “the wealthy.” But people can leave, capital can leave, businesses can grow elsewhere, and the burden shifts onto those who remain trapped here.
Rhode Island needs more honesty from Smith Hill. To protect vulnerable people, build a stronger economy. For better schools, demand accountability. For affordable housing, stop making it expensive to build. For independence from Washington, stop budgeting as a dependent.
Rhode Island families deserve more than a narrative built around fear of Washington. They deserve a state government willing to admit these problems were not imposed by one federal administration.
They were built here. And they can only be fixed here.